SenelXStella , SenelXChloe or SenelXShirley ?

SymphonicAbyssLegend · Joined: 16 Jul 2010 Posts: 2005 Location: The Legacy

My favorite is SenelxStella, but he should probably have someone else beside him now that Stella is dead. I don't really like the idea of "The older sister is dead, so let's go with the younger sister", so I say SenelxChloe post-game. I know Shirley has feelings for Senel, but he loved Stella; not Shirley. Not to mention the way he tried to save Shirley seemed rushed and his way of getting her to stop going !genocide on the Orerines. I don't have any actual problem with Shirley herself, but I don't like her paired with Senel.
_________________

~Credit to Augla for the EmilxRubia luvvies~

"Moses, quit playing around; get serious!"
"But Moses is always serious."
"You tell 'em, Norma!"
"For that's as serious as he gets."
~
Fighting for the localization of Tales~!

Ayuu · Joined: 17 Feb 2011 Posts: 12

I like Chloe and Stella, but I think Shirley has a lot more right than Chloe, not as much as Stella Shirley des ... but the beginning of the game she liked Senel DX
_________________

'' You are the Key to my Heart ~ ''

KrossWinter · Joined: 22 Feb 2011 Posts: 25

I have to side with those who are saying SenelxStella pre-game, SenelxChloe post-game.

I'm entirely agreeing with Shadowfox. SenelxShirley may be what the game slated towards, but in terms of probability and rationality I have to say even i if Senel wanted to start over with Shirley, the past they had would still influence the way he feels about her. As a sister. Another thing is, I believe Senel to be too honorable to date his recently deceased girlfriend's little sister.

Furthering this, all of Senel's story titles include 'Brother'. I think that helps to make it a pretty clear cut. And Chloe fills the lover role much better than Shirley, who was practically molded to be the sister. Through the entire game, the development between Senel and Chloe is shown and nurtured. Also, (and correct me if I'm wrong, not sure if I remember right.) isn't there a fun little scene between Chloe and Senel when she tries to wake him up in the character quests?

On the SenelxChloe note, one side is obviously returning feelings, while Senel is being thick-headed. But the fact he cares for her differently than a sister is consistently set up through the game. And Chloe's character quest does nothing to dissuade this.

Blasphemy · Posted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 10:31 am Post subject:

^I like this post. And that Raven avi.
_________________

"Thou art I, and I am thou. From the sea of thy soul I cometh. I am Orpheus, master of strings..."
-Orpheus (Persona 3)
P3+4 FC
Atelier Iris FC

Ryuuka of the 7th Flame · Posted: Tue Mar 01, 2011 9:52 pm Post subject:

My views have been stated far better than I could have managed for the most part.
I still don't see Senel escaping from his "engagement" to Shirley but it's made very clear that he'd be better off with Chloe, whom I deem more deserving of his affection.
_________________
The ember is dust before the wind...

Grim · Posted: Wed Mar 02, 2011 4:20 am Post subject:

Shirley deserves a brick in the face.

Anyways, in a more serious tone I think SenelxShirley is a terrible if not horrible pairing. I think it would be shallow of Senel to use Shirley as a replacement for her sister, and Shirley is selfish for wanting more out of Senel more than a friend/brotherly figure.

I always liked the SenelxChloe pair, it always made more sense and much less creepy.
_________________

Thanks to jazz for the avy but I forgot who made my sig, please pm me sig creator so I cna add you here!